Highland Haven Real Estate Market Trends

I’m Robbie English, REALTOR and Broker at Uncommon Highland Lakes Realty. This page is about what’s already happened in the Highland Haven market, recent price movement and inventory levels over the past year or so. If you’re trying to figure out where things are headed instead, I’ve laid that out separately on my market forecast page.

Why a Handful of Sales Can Swing the Numbers Here

Highland Haven is a small lake city on the eastern shore of Lake LBJ in Burnet County with only a few hundred residents, so a handful of closings in a given quarter can move average price and days-on-market figures more than they would in a large metro. One lakefront sale at the high end can pull an average up even if most other homes sold for less. That’s why I look at individual comparable sales with clients rather than leaning on citywide averages alone.

How I Actually Read Small-Town Market Data

A town Highland Haven’s size doesn’t produce enough monthly transactions to support the kind of trend charts you’d see for a city like Austin, and treating it like it does leads to bad conclusions. Instead of watching a single average price line, I look at three things side by side: what’s genuinely comparable to the specific property in question, how that comparable sold relative to its own list price, and how long it actually sat before going under contract. A citywide average can look flat or even down in a quarter where every individual comparable sale actually performed well, simply because the mix of what sold that quarter skewed toward smaller or interior homes instead of waterfront. If a number I quote you doesn’t match what you’re seeing in a listing portal’s citywide chart, this mismatch is usually why, and it’s a good reason to ask rather than assume the portal’s number applies to your specific situation.

Where Pricing Has Stood

Home values across Burnet County broadly have held up over the past year, even with mortgage rates staying elevated. That’s held true here too, though Highland Haven doesn’t see enough transactions in a given month to generate a reliable trend line on its own. Because it sits close to both Marble Falls and Horseshoe Bay, pricing pressure in those markets tends to show up here too, particularly when Horseshoe Bay gets more expensive and buyers start looking at Highland Haven for similar lake access at a lower entry point.

Where Inventory Has Stood

Active inventory in Highland Haven has stayed thin, which is typical for a town this size rather than a sign of anything unusual. True waterfront and dock-access homes make up a small share of what’s on the market at any given time, and those tend to move faster than interior lots once they’re listed. That pattern has held steady over the past several cycles I’ve tracked.

What Recent Activity Signals

Elevated rates have slowed decision timelines more than they’ve killed demand outright. A lot of Highland Haven buyers, retirees and second-home buyers especially, are flexible on when they move, so higher rates tend to stretch out how long a search takes rather than take buyers out of the market entirely.

What This Means Depending on Whether You’re Buying or Selling

If you’re buying, thin inventory means the right property might not come up on your exact timeline, so it helps to have a standing search running rather than checking back occasionally. It also means you may have less room to negotiate on a genuinely well-priced waterfront listing, since there are fewer comparable options for a seller to worry about losing you to. If you’re selling, the flip side applies: pricing against a citywide average instead of the handful of homes that actually compare to yours is one of the most common mistakes I see, and it cuts both ways. Overpricing off a skewed average can mean sitting unsold longer than a well-priced comparable would have, while underpricing off a soft-looking average can leave real money on the table if your specific home and lot are stronger than the average implies.

How Highland Haven Compares to Its Neighbors

Highland Haven sits in an interesting spot relative to Granite Shoals and Kingsland, its closest Lake LBJ neighbors. All three sit on the same lake and draw a similar retiree and second-home buyer, but Highland Haven’s smaller footprint means it never develops the deeper inventory those two towns can carry in a strong season. That’s not a knock on the town, it’s just a structural fact worth knowing going in. If you’ve widened a search to include all three and you’re seeing more options in Granite Shoals or Kingsland at a given moment, that’s typical, not a sign Highland Haven itself is somehow underperforming. It usually just means fewer owners happened to list there that particular month.

What tends to draw buyers to Highland Haven specifically, rather than its larger neighbors, is the quieter, lower-key feel and the fact that it’s still close enough to Marble Falls and Horseshoe Bay to reach groceries, healthcare, and dining without much of a drive. If quiet and proximity matter more to you than a wider selection to choose from, that trade-off usually works in Highland Haven’s favor.

Thinking About Selling?

Your Name(Required)

First Last

Your Email(Required)

Your Phone(Required)

Your Home Address(Required)

Street Address City ZIP / Postal Code

Property Type(Required)

What are you thinking about doing?(Required)

Consent(Required)

By submitting this form, you agree that Robbie English and representatives of Uncommon Realty may contact you by phone, email, or text regarding your inquiry. Consent is not a condition of purchasing any property, goods, or services. Message and data rates may apply.

CAPTCHA

Phone

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

A property priced against generic Hill Country trends instead of actual recent Highland Haven and Highland Lakes sales can sit on the market longer than it should, or leave money on the table if it’s underpriced.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why don’t you publish a specific median price or days-on-market number for Highland Haven?

Because the town’s sales volume is too low, month to month, for a single number to be reliable. A handful of closings can swing an average significantly, so I’d rather walk you through the specific comparable sales for your situation than quote a citywide figure that may not apply.

Does Horseshoe Bay’s market affect Highland Haven?

Yes, indirectly. When Horseshoe Bay pricing climbs, some buyers look at Highland Haven for similar Lake LBJ access at a lower entry point, which can put upward pressure on Highland Haven pricing as a result.

Is now a good time to sell in Highland Haven?

It depends heavily on your specific property and how it compares to what’s genuinely on the market right now, not on a general market average. I’d rather look at your home directly than answer that in the abstract.

Where can I see what’s actually sold recently in Highland Haven?

I keep a running list on my recently sold homes page, which reflects real closed transactions rather than an aggregated average.

Where to Get Real Numbers

I track Highland Haven sales closely because I work this market regularly, and I’d rather give you a specific read on your situation than a generic trend line. If you want to see what’s actually closed recently, I keep a running list on my recently sold homes page. If you want to know what’s happening right now, whether you’re buying or selling, reach out and I’ll walk you through the current comparable sales myself.

You Might Also Find These Helpful

I touched on a related piece of this here too: Highland Haven Offer Negotiation: Multiple Offers & Post-Inspection.

Robbie English, REALTOR, Broker at Uncommon Highland Lakes Realty.