Ultimate Sellers Guide: Top Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Your Home

If you’re thinking about selling, there’s one truth that can save you a lot of time, money, and frustration: how you approach the process can make or break your outcome. I’ve seen sellers trip up for reasons that were completely avoidable—and that’s exactly why this guide exists. We’re diving into the top mistakes to avoid when selling your home so you don’t have to learn the hard way. And yes, we’re going to get specific, because vague advice won’t help you stand out in a competitive market.

I’m Robbie English, Broker and REALTOR with Uncommon Realty, and I’ve spent decades helping sellers achieve more than they thought possible. I’m also a national real estate speaker and instructor, teaching professionals across the country how to do real estate better. The knowledge I bring to my clients isn’t theory—it’s strategy, tested and proven. Let’s talk about what not to do when selling your home and how working with the right agent—me—can set you up for success.

TL;DR – Top Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Your Home

1. Skipping pre-sale prep makes your home less appealing.
2. Overpricing chases away serious buyers fast.
3. Bad listing photos hurt your chances before showings even start.
4. Weak marketing limits your reach and response.
5. Ignoring feedback or trends can stall your sale.

Neglecting the Power of Preparation

Most homes that linger on the market longer than they should have one thing in common: they weren’t ready when the listing went live. Think of it like going on a date wearing your yard work clothes—bad first impression, right? The same thing happens when buyers walk into a space that looks tired, cluttered, or unfinished.

Buyers want to imagine their lives in your home, and that’s tough to do when they’re focused on peeling paint or overflowing closets. Walk through your house like a buyer would. What stands out? What needs fixing? You don’t have to remodel, but you do need to repair. Fix leaky faucets, paint where necessary, clean everything, and make sure every room has a purpose. Staging helps too—it highlights your home’s strengths without being over-the-top.

This early prep work is your secret weapon. If you skip it, you’ll join the long list of sellers who made one of the biggest mistakes when selling your home.

Getting Greedy with the Price

Everyone wants top dollar. But the mistake comes when sellers confuse “what I want” with “what the market allows.”

Overpricing is one of the most common and damaging errors. You might think your home is worth more because of the memories you made there, the upgrades you added, or the price your neighbor got last year. But buyers are looking at cold hard facts, not feelings.

When your price is too high, you scare off serious buyers who might’ve made a great offer if you’d started where you should have. Worse, your home sits, collects dust, and becomes what agents call “stale.” Then you reduce the price, which sends up a red flag. Buyers wonder what’s wrong with it.

I use data-driven strategies to set prices, looking at recent sales, local competition, and buyer behavior patterns. And I’ll tell you the truth, not just what sounds good. That’s the difference between a listing that sells fast and one that doesn’t move.

Underestimating the Role of Professional Photography

You’re not just selling a home. You’re selling a vision, an opportunity, a future. Most of that vision starts online. That means your listing photos are your first showing. And blurry cell phone shots aren’t going to cut it.

I work with professional photographers who know how to capture a home’s angles, light, and personality. We’re not just snapping rooms—we’re building emotional connection. If a buyer isn’t hooked by the photos, they’re not booking a showing. And without showings, you have no shot at offers.

Outdated, dark, or poorly framed images tell buyers, “This house isn’t worth your time.” Don’t make that mistake. Investing in quality photography is one of the simplest ways to avoid another one of the mistakes when selling your home that can derail your momentum from the start.

Failing to Go All-In with Marketing

Putting your home on the MLS is not a marketing plan. Neither is throwing it up on a few social platforms and crossing your fingers.

Effective marketing means telling your home’s story to the right people, in the right places, with the right message. I create custom campaigns using a mix of digital tools, social media, virtual tours, targeted email, and sometimes even strategic print. This isn’t one-size-fits-all—every home has a different angle, and it’s my job to find and amplify it.

Most sellers who struggle either don’t know how to market or hire someone who doesn’t. With me, that’s not a risk. I’ve mastered real estate marketing because I’ve studied what works and refined my approach over decades. If your home isn’t marketed well, buyers won’t even know it’s available—or worse, they’ll scroll right past it.

Being Caught Off Guard by Showings

Imagine a buyer walking in with excitement—only to be greeted by dirty dishes, unmade beds, and weird smells. They’re not coming back.

Showings can happen at any time. You have to be ready. That doesn’t mean living in a museum, but it does mean creating a welcoming atmosphere every single day. Clean. Tidy. Well-lit. Comfortable temperature. Let in the light, leave soft music playing, and keep pets out of the way. Showings are your chance to shine.

You only get one first impression. If your home looks like it just hosted a frat party, that’s the lasting memory buyers will take with them.

Ignoring Feedback or Market Signals

Feedback is a gift, even when it stings. If buyers keep saying your home feels dark, guess what—it’s time to change the lighting. If multiple people say the price feels high, that’s a market signal you shouldn’t ignore.

Selling isn’t static. It’s a dynamic process that needs adjustment. I monitor buyer activity and feedback closely, so we can pivot fast if needed. Sellers who dig in and refuse to listen often find themselves with a home that doesn’t sell, no matter how great it is.

My role is to interpret the market and guide you through it. When you trust my feedback, you position yourself to succeed.

Letting Emotions Hijack the Negotiations

You love your home. You’ve put time and energy into it. But when it comes to negotiating, you need to take a step back.

Deals fall apart all the time because sellers get emotional. They reject reasonable offers out of pride or take buyer requests personally. That’s a fast track to frustration.

I act as your buffer, your strategist, and your advocate. I negotiate from a place of facts, not feelings, and I’m always focused on your bottom line. Selling your home is a business transaction. When we treat it that way, we get better outcomes.

The Advantage of Working with Robbie English

Here’s where you have an edge most sellers don’t: you’re not working with just anyone. You’re working with me, Robbie English—Broker, REALTOR, national speaker, instructor, and relentless advocate for my clients. I’ve trained real estate professionals nationwide, and I bring that same insight to the table for you.

When you’re trying to avoid the top mistakes to avoid when selling your home, it’s not enough to hope for the best. You need someone who knows how to navigate the market with confidence and precision. Someone who doesn’t just follow industry standards, but helps define them.

That’s what I do.

I tailor every listing plan to the unique needs of the property and the goals of my clients. I use cutting-edge tools combined with tried-and-true techniques that work. Most importantly, I listen. This isn’t just about selling your house—it’s about helping you reach your next chapter with clarity and ease.

And while other agents may make promises, I deliver results.

Ready to Get It Right the First Time?

Selling your home doesn’t have to be a headache. When you avoid the most common mistakes and have expert guidance every step of the way, the process becomes a whole lot smoother—and more successful.

Avoid the pitfalls. Skip the stress. Sell smart.

Let’s make your move count.

Reach out today, and let’s build a strategy that puts your goals first—and gets your home sold on your terms.  I’m Robbie English with Uncommon Realty.